I used ChatGPT for the first building block and while ChatGPT addressed the topic well, its use of language is awful--so bad that it smacks of a soulless bureaucrat or an academic hack. Worse, it doesn't offer any specific examples or define terms like "balanced and holistic approach." Annoyingly, it also uses condescending hack speak and brain-deadening cliches such as "stemming from the interplay of social pressures" and "illuminate the profound challenges." It also cowardly avoids the argument. I says losing weight "resembles a futile endeavour." I don't care about what resembles what. I want to know what your actual argument is.
Building Block #1 for Losing Weight Essay: 2 Paragraphs
For the first paragraph, summarize the major points in Xochitl Gonzalez’s essay “In the Age of Ozempic, What’s the Point of Working Out?," Harriet Brown's "The Weight of the Evidence" and Sandra Aamodt's "Why You Can't Lose Weight on a Diet" in order to emphasize the crisis between the stress and anxiety over body condition and self-worth.
For the second paragraph, present an argumentative claim or thesis that in the context of the above writers answers the question: Is losing weight a fool's errand? Be sure to map out 3 or 4 reasons in your thesis.
Chat GPT Response:
First Paragraph: Xochitl Gonzalez's essay "In the Age of Ozempic, What’s the Point of Working Out?" discusses the complexities of weight loss in a society heavily focused on appearance. Harriet Brown's "The Weight of the Evidence" examines the contradictory and often unreliable nature of weight loss studies, revealing how society's obsession with weight can contribute to stress and anxiety. Sandra Aamodt's "Why You Can't Lose Weight on a Diet" delves into the biological and psychological factors that make sustained weight loss through dieting a challenging endeavor, highlighting the toll it takes on mental health. Collectively, these works underscore the crisis stemming from the interplay of societal pressures, unrealistic beauty standards, and the emotional toll of striving for a certain body image.
Second Paragraph (Thesis): In light of the insights provided by Gonzalez, Brown, and Aamodt, it can be argued that the pursuit of weight loss, in the contemporary context, often resembles a futile endeavor. This assertion can be supported by several reasons. Firstly, the pervasive influence of unrealistic body ideals perpetuated by media and societal standards sets individuals up for disappointment and anxiety. Secondly, the conflicting and unreliable information surrounding weight loss methods, as demonstrated by Brown, undermines people's confidence in their efforts. Thirdly, Aamodt's exploration of the biological mechanisms that resist sustained weight loss indicates that the body's response to dieting can lead to metabolic adaptations and psychological distress. Lastly, the emotional toll of weight loss pursuits, as highlighted across the three essays, contributes to stress and negatively impacts overall well-being. Collectively, these reasons illuminate the profound challenges and adverse consequences associated with the relentless pursuit of weight loss in today's society, suggesting that a more balanced and holistic approach to health and self-worth is necessary.
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.