
Angelo and I agree that it is disappointing that someone as educated and cosmopolitan as Juan Williams has such an irrational fear of Muslims, but we both think NPR made a big mistake in firing him. As Angelo writes:
For those of you who are saying that NPR had a "right" to fire Williams ("employers can fire employees") I think you are missing the point. Most of us aren't saying they had no "right" to can Williams, but instead we're saying it was a bad decision.
It's similar to the NYC mosque argument----of course people have a "right" to build the mosque (assuming it meets code and zoning requirements). Again, it becomes more a question of the wisdom of doing it. In the Juan Williams case, I'm a conservative guy who normally doesn't see eye to eye with Williams' political views. But I find that he frames his arguments well and seems to be intelligent and very well reasoned. Debate makes the world a far more interesting place and I enjoy hearing opposing points of view from people who are measured and informed, like Juan Williams.
I really didn't understand his "fear" or "anxiety" about traditionally dressed Muslims being on the same plane with him. As a Washington, DC resident, I see this all the time---I've flown with Muslims, been in line at banks with them, eaten in the Mall food courts with them, talked to Muslim business owners while eating at their restaurants, filling up at their gas stations, etc. They're just people to me, and I doubt they'd board a plane in traditional dress to blow it up. But the fact is, Williams just said what he felt. It shouldn't have lead to his firing in my opinion. NPR shouldn't be funded by taxes anyway----so I'd have defunded them years ago, not just because of this. Let George Soros write a check to them or let their listeners pay----they are not neutral enough to warrant my taxes going to them. It would be like asking Tom W. to send a check to Fox News.
Recent Comments