Bill writes:
I ended up with a Sony ICF-F10, about $13 on Amazon. My impression of it is that it is the perfect office radio; decent quality, decent sound, decent performance. I'm sure it could serve as a basic DX machine if you wanted, although it's not a top performer, but in an office environment you aren't going to be DXing at work, I'd guess. Anyway, with the florescents and computer widgetry about you wouldn't pick up any weak signals if you did.
In short, a good practical radio, able to provide decent listening on any signal solid enough that you'd want to actually listen to it.
I would guess that it will run about twenty minutes short of forever on those two D cells, so the lack of an AC power socket is not a problem. All the more so because in an office environment that's going to introduce even more noise into the radio, so you'd be better off running it on batteries anyway.
It's reassuring that there are still decent radios like this available for cheap. Out here in The Sticks I consider a modest radio to be basic survival equipment. When the power goes out a portable FM radio will keep you informed. If things are really bad then AM at night can bring you information from hundreds of miles away; this radio will pull in powerful signals from that far, easily.
Of course it's typical that the US version costs more than a redecorated model meant to be sold somewhere else. We're made out of money and don't mind being ripped off, right? You can still get this Middle East model online, and you know what? It tunes in English-language broadcasts just as well as any other.
Based on his comment about the two D batteries, it sounds like Bill is referring to the ICF-F10, not the ICF-S10 pocket radio.
Posted by: Gary | March 20, 2013 at 05:00 PM
Gary, I think you're right. Thanks.
Posted by: herculodge | March 20, 2013 at 05:08 PM
Hello all,
If you think that is something? Take a look at this Sony radio that looks just like the ICF-F10 but has a 3rd band. A shortwave band SW - 5 , 9/18 MHz. The model is Sony ICF-F12S. I could not find it on Amazon but it sure would be nice to try one out.
Link
http://blogdogeorgec.blogspot.com/2009/03/sony-icf-f12s.html
Chris in Michigan
Posted by: Chris in Michigan | March 20, 2013 at 05:29 PM
I'm waiting for a comparison between the ICF F10 and the ICF 38. Every time I get a 38, I end up giving it away to some one, so I can't presently make the comparison myself. These two radios are comparable, though. The F10 has a fuller audio quality, but the 38 may have slightly better reception. Yet, there's a price difference of about $12.
I wonder if - in spite of all the claims to the contrary - analog dial radios with a mere two bands are growing increasingly popular. They have an immediacy to them, with nothing to "set up" or "program." I think we middle-aged guys who have done our best to adjust to the mad technological race - learning computer and all in our forties or so, and finding it to seem a bit unnatural - get a certain relief when we find such simple radios. They give us a chance to take a breath and reconsider that we ultimately don't like so much technology - or at least, so much constant change and sophistication in technology. There's nothing like clicking an "on" switch, choosing a band, turning a frequency dial, and then adjusting the volume knob. Ahhh, so easy.
At least, that's where I find myself these days.
Posted by: Tim | March 20, 2013 at 09:25 PM
To give a couple examples of the popularity of simple radios, on Amazon there are presently 691 reviews of the Sony ICF 38, and 1,163 reviews of the Sony ICF S10MK2. Surely these numbers mean something.
Posted by: Tim | March 20, 2013 at 09:34 PM
Tim
I have both radios: - Sony ICF-F10 and Sony ICF -38.
Sony ISF-F10 has better tone. Important factor is a two D buttery in F10.When I turn on F10, very often I turn knob by 75-90 percent volume. It is laud and sounds good. Since I bought F10 I listen few days for few hours every day!!!! It has a same sound .I like tuning knob and volume knob. Sony ICF-10 has lighter plastic, no handle,-strap.no AC, only DC. FM-frequency selectivity and sensitivity both radio same.AM-I think selectivity is very similar or slightly better on ICF-38, but sensitivity slightly better on F10.
Sony ICF -38 better build, has handle, no knobs AC cord inside radio, and 4 DC- AA buttery with intensive listening faster drain. ICF-38 has green tuning leg and better antenna movement by 360 degree.
Sony ICF-F10 doesn’t have tuning leg and only 180 degree antenna movement. Each radio has own benefit. My preference is a Sony ICF-F10 because better sound for me, and long life buttery, I don’t have to looking for AC plug.
I hope its help.
Cheers.
Val
Posted by: val | March 21, 2013 at 01:07 AM
I have to agree with Tim. Although I am older,64,I don't think my increasing appreciation of simple analog radios has anything to do with the good old days.
They are just easier to use.
Ive bought and sold maybe a dozen digital SW radios in the past few years. After a while I realized I was spending more time fiddling with them than listening to them.
Last year I got a BNIB Grundig G5 on E-bay for $125.00. The last production run that has the anti-static diodes already installed. I've always wanted one.
Great radio, despite the memory system from hell.
(100 pages with 7 slots per page? Who's idea was this?)
After a while it seemed more of a gadget than a radio. Now it sits in a box in my closet untouched.
Ive got an ICF-38 I listen to all the time.
Great radio, cost $25.00
Posted by: Michael Brent | March 21, 2013 at 05:14 PM
The same goes for me, Michael. It isn't nostalgia; it's an honest preference for the simple. And the results are again the same for me: a simpler radio means more actual listening, and less messing around with the impressive features.
Posted by: Tim | March 21, 2013 at 09:06 PM
Just got an F10. Haven't had time to make serious tests, but I'm more than impressed. Good natural sound, simple to operate. Seems more sensitive than expected, both bands are full of listenable signals. Surprised at how good FM music sounds. At $13 this could be the best value in radios right now. If you need a workhorse for the garage or the yard, I don't see how it can be beat.
Posted by: pfmurphy | March 21, 2013 at 09:41 PM