Interrogating the Maudlin Condition as a Form of Moral Depravity and an Impediment to Happiness

1C Essay 2: Exploring the Maudlin Disposition as a Form of Moral Depravity and an Impediment to Happiness

Interrogating the Maudlin Condition as a Form of Moral Depravity and an Impediment to Happiness

 

Choice A: “Winter Dreams” and “The Swimmer”

 

Addressing the quest for a happy and moral soul, Cicero in his Tusculan Disputations observes that the soul must be “tranquilized by restraint and consistency.” In such a state, the soul “neither pines away in distress, nor is broken down by fear, nor consumed with a thirst of longing in pursuit of some ambition, nor maudlin in the exuberance of meaningless eagerness--he is the wise man of whom we are in quest, he is the happy man.” Therefore, we can conclude that unhappiness and misery are the result of the maudlin disposition, which we can define as having the “exuberance of meaningless eagerness”--investing our emotions in false paths: idolizing people, things, and pleasure and investing our hopes in false cures or fraudulent panaceas for our ailments. The maudlin person invests so much emotion and thought in these meaningless enthusiasms that they cannot engage and connect in the real world with any meaning or coherence. Disconnected from life and others, the maudlin person seeks refuge in fantasies of the perfect life. The therapist and author Phil Stutz calls this imagined perfect life a “Moment Frozen in Time.” Constantly craving these Moments Frozen in Time, the maudlin person becomes drunk and intoxicated by these fantasies of perfection while real life passes them by. Unable to engage the real world or find meaningful connections with others, the maudlin person retreats into a world of 

excessive, drunken and foolish sentimentality for anything that has been elevated to something undeserving of such excessive emotion. Therefore, to be a maudlin person is to be fragile, weak, immature, and unhinged because to be maudlin is to be disconnected from reality and from other people. To be in this state of disconnection and loneliness, maudlin people rely on their excessive sentimentality and misguided affections to compensate and escape from their miserable loneliness and disconnection. Another egregious flaw of the maudlin person is that they confuse the object or idea of their maudlin emotions with reality when in fact the cause of their sentimentality is a mirage or a chimera. Therefore, we can conclude that maudlin people are disoriented, unhinged, weak, fragile souls who console themselves feebly with their hollow sentimentality, anguish, and regret. All the while, they retreat more and more into Moments Frozen in Time. In the context of the maudlin personalty type, write an essay that addresses the claim that the two fictional characters Dexter Green in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s short story “Winter Dreams” and Neddy Merrill in John Cheever’s short story “The Swimmer” have squandered their time on Earth, have retreated into Moments Frozen in Time, and disconnected themselves from the meaningful relationships that are necessary for a happy and fulfilled life because they have succumbed to the maudlin condition. Be sure to have a Works Cited page in MLA format with a minimum of 4 sources. 

 

Choice B: Uncut Gems and Private Life

 

Addressing the quest for a happy and moral soul, Cicero in his Tusculan Disputations observes that the soul must be “tranquilized by restraint and consistency.” In such a state, the soul “neither pines away in distress, nor is broken down by fear, nor consumed with a thirst of longing in pursuit of some ambition, nor maudlin in the exuberance of meaningless eagerness--he is the wise man of whom we are in quest, he is the happy man.” Therefore, we can conclude that unhappiness and misery are the result of the maudlin disposition, which we can define as having the “exuberance of meaningless eagerness”--investing our emotions in false paths: idolizing people, things, and pleasure and investing our hopes in false cures or fraudulent panaceas for our ailments. The maudlin person invests so much emotion and thought in these meaningless enthusiasms that they cannot engage and connect in the real world with any meaning or coherence. Disconnected from life and others, the maudlin person seeks refuge in fantasies of the perfect life. The therapist and author Phil Stutz calls this imagined perfect life a “Moment Frozen in Time.” Constantly craving these Moments Frozen in Time, the maudlin person becomes drunk and intoxicated by these fantasies of perfection while real life passes them by. Unable to engage the real world or find meaningful connections with others, the maudlin person retreats into a world of 

excessive, drunken and foolish sentimentality for anything that has been elevated to something undeserving of such excessive emotion. Therefore, to be a maudlin person is to be fragile, weak, immature, and unhinged because to be maudlin is to be disconnected from reality and from other people. To be in this state of disconnection and loneliness, maudlin people rely on their excessive sentimentality and misguided affections to compensate and escape from their miserable loneliness and disconnection. Another egregious flaw of the maudlin person is that they confuse the object or idea of their maudlin emotions with reality when in fact the cause of their sentimentality is a mirage or a chimera. Therefore, we can conclude that maudlin people are disoriented, unhinged, weak, fragile souls who console themselves feebly with their hollow sentimentality, anguish, and regret. All the while, they retreat more and more into Moments Frozen in Time. In the context of the maudlin personality type, write a 1,200-word essay that compares the maudlin disposition of Howard Ratner from the movie Uncut Gems, as a man overcome with excessive love for a gem that he believes will heal his wounded masculinity, with the couple from the movie Private Life who have excessive zeal to have a child as a way of healing their wounded marriage. Be sure to have a Works Cited page in MLA format with a minimum of 4 sources. 

ChatGPT Response to Choice A (6-8-24):

The Maudlin Disposition: Dexter Green and Neddy Merrill’s Squandered Lives

Cicero’s insight into the quest for a happy and moral soul underscores the necessity of restraint and consistency for achieving tranquility. He warns against the maudlin disposition, characterized by an “exuberance of meaningless eagerness” that leads individuals to invest their emotions in false paths, rendering them disconnected from reality and incapable of forming meaningful connections. This ancient wisdom resonates through the lives of Dexter Green in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “Winter Dreams” and Neddy Merrill in John Cheever’s “The Swimmer.” Both characters epitomize the maudlin condition, squandering their time on Earth and retreating into “Moments Frozen in Time,” disconnected from the relationships essential for a fulfilled life.

Dexter Green in “Winter Dreams”: The Illusion of Love and Success

Dexter Green’s life is a poignant example of how the maudlin disposition can lead to the squandering of one’s potential and the erosion of meaningful connections. Dexter is consumed by his pursuit of wealth and social status, driven by an obsessive desire to win the love of Judy Jones, a symbol of his aspirations. His infatuation with Judy represents Cicero’s “exuberance of meaningless eagerness.” Judy is not a real person to Dexter but an idealized figure, a “Moment Frozen in Time” that embodies his dreams of success and validation.

Dexter’s maudlin obsession blinds him to the emptiness of his pursuits. Despite achieving financial success, he remains unfulfilled and disconnected. His relationships are shallow, driven by ambition rather than genuine connection. Dexter’s fixation on Judy prevents him from seeing the reality of her fickle nature and the superficiality of their relationship. When Judy finally expresses interest in him, it is too late—Dexter’s dreams have already lost their allure, leaving him hollow and disillusioned. His life, marked by missed opportunities for real connection and personal growth, is a testament to the destructive power of the maudlin disposition.

Neddy Merrill in “The Swimmer”: The Illusion of Eternal Youth

Neddy Merrill’s journey in John Cheever’s “The Swimmer” is a surreal exploration of the maudlin condition. Neddy sets out to swim across the county, pool by pool, envisioning himself as an enduring symbol of vitality and success. This journey, however, is not grounded in reality but in a fantasy of perpetual youth and invincibility—a clear manifestation of Cicero’s “exuberance of meaningless eagerness.” Neddy’s swim is a literal and figurative retreat into a “Moment Frozen in Time,” where he is immune to the passage of time and the consequences of his actions.

As Neddy progresses, the reality of his life gradually intrudes upon his delusion. He encounters pools that are abandoned, locked, or inhabited by people who no longer recognize him. These encounters reveal the true state of his life: financial ruin, estranged relationships, and the passing of time that he has ignored. Neddy’s refusal to acknowledge these realities epitomizes the maudlin disposition, characterized by a disconnection from life and others. His journey ends in despair as he arrives at his own empty, decaying home, a stark contrast to the vibrant life he imagined. Neddy’s tragic end underscores the futility of living in a fantasy and the inevitable isolation that comes from disconnecting oneself from reality.

The Cost of Maudlin Obsessions: Disconnection and Isolation

Both Dexter Green and Neddy Merrill squander their potential for happiness and fulfillment by succumbing to the maudlin condition. Their lives are marked by an obsessive pursuit of illusions—Dexter’s fixation on wealth and Judy Jones, and Neddy’s delusion of eternal youth. These pursuits lead them to invest their emotions in false paths, disconnecting them from meaningful relationships and the realities of their lives.

Dexter’s success is hollow, achieved at the cost of genuine connections and personal fulfillment. His eventual disillusionment reveals the emptiness of his dreams and the shallow nature of his relationships. Similarly, Neddy’s journey through the pools is a metaphor for his denial of reality and the passage of time. His final realization of his lost life and broken relationships comes too late, leaving him isolated and despondent.

Conclusion: The Lessons of Dexter and Neddy

Cicero’s wisdom on the tranquil soul highlights the dangers of the maudlin disposition, a lesson vividly illustrated by the lives of Dexter Green and Neddy Merrill. Their stories serve as cautionary tales about the perils of investing in illusions and neglecting the real connections that bring true happiness and fulfillment. Dexter and Neddy’s lives are marked by a retreat into “Moments Frozen in Time,” resulting in disconnection, loneliness, and ultimately, a profound sense of loss. Through their narratives, we are reminded of the importance of grounding our aspirations in reality and valuing the meaningful relationships that enrich our lives.

 

 

4o

 

ChatGPT Response to Choice B (6-8-24):

The Maudlin Disposition in Modern Cinema: A Comparative Analysis of Howard Ratner in Uncut Gems and the Couple in Private Life

Cicero's observation that the soul must be “tranquilized by restraint and consistency” to achieve true happiness resonates profoundly in the modern context. His identification of a maudlin disposition—marked by “exuberance of meaningless eagerness”—offers a timeless caution against investing our emotions in false idols and fraudulent panaceas. This concept finds vivid expression in the characters of Howard Ratner from Uncut Gems and the couple from Private Life. Both narratives portray individuals who, in their maudlin states, invest excessive emotion and expectation in objects or goals that ultimately disconnect them from reality and deeper human connections.

Howard Ratner in Uncut Gems: The Quest for Masculine Redemption

Howard Ratner, the protagonist of Uncut Gems, exemplifies the maudlin disposition through his obsessive pursuit of a rare black opal. For Ratner, the gem is not merely a valuable asset but a symbol of hope and redemption. He believes that the opal will bring him the wealth and success needed to restore his sense of self-worth and masculinity. His fixation on the gem blinds him to the realities of his precarious situation—his crumbling marriage, mounting debts, and the dangerous individuals he owes money to.

Ratner's maudlin obsession with the opal is characterized by an “exuberance of meaningless eagerness.” He sees the gem as a magical solution to his problems, a “Moment Frozen in Time” that promises an idealized future. This fixation renders him incapable of engaging with the real world. His relationships deteriorate as he becomes increasingly consumed by the fantasy of a perfect outcome. Ratner's life spirals out of control, driven by a misguided belief in the gem's power, illustrating Cicero's warning against the maudlin disposition. His story is a tragic illustration of how such obsessive zeal can lead to disconnection, loneliness, and ultimately, ruin.

The Couple in Private Life: A Desperate Pursuit of Parenthood

In Private Life, we encounter a couple whose maudlin disposition manifests in their desperate efforts to have a child. Richard and Rachel Grimes view parenthood as the panacea for their marital struggles and personal insecurities. Their excessive zeal to conceive a child leads them down a path of invasive medical procedures, financial strain, and emotional turbulence. Much like Ratner, their obsession is driven by the belief that achieving their goal will mend their wounded relationship and bring fulfillment.

The couple's fixation on having a child mirrors Ratner's obsession with the opal. They invest all their hopes and emotions in this singular pursuit, creating an imagined “Moment Frozen in Time” where having a child will solve all their problems. This excessive sentimentality blinds them to the realities of their situation—the toll on their mental health, the strain on their relationship, and the ethical complexities of their choices. Their maudlin pursuit disconnects them from the present, leading to a life dominated by anticipation and disappointment.

Comparing Maudlin Dispositions: Illusions and Realities

Both Uncut Gems and Private Life illustrate the perils of a maudlin disposition. Howard Ratner and the Grimes couple are united by their excessive, misplaced zeal. Their stories highlight the consequences of idolizing objects or goals as cures for deeper emotional and existential wounds.

Ratner's belief in the opal as a cure for his wounded masculinity is a poignant example of how such illusions can lead to self-destruction. His maudlin pursuit not only alienates him from his loved ones but also accelerates his downfall, culminating in his tragic end. Similarly, the Grimes couple's quest for a child as a remedy for their fractured marriage reveals the fragility of relying on external solutions for internal problems. Their journey is fraught with frustration and heartbreak, underscoring the futility of their excessive zeal.

Conclusion: The Tragic Cost of Maudlin Obsessions

In both films, the characters’ maudlin dispositions highlight the dangers of excessive sentimentality and misguided affections. Cicero’s wisdom reminds us that true happiness and stability come from inner restraint and consistency, not from external fixes or imagined perfect moments. Howard Ratner and the Grimes couple embody the fragility and disconnection that result from investing in false idols. Their stories serve as modern parables, urging us to seek genuine connections and realistic solutions rather than retreating into fantasies and futile obsessions.